A decade of increasing complexity in patients sustaining a hip fracture in England, Wales and Northern Ireland

A decade of increasing complexity in patients sustaining a hip fracture in England, Wales and Northern Ireland

Hip fracture remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality among older adults and places a substantial burden on health and social care. Using data from the National Hip Fracture Database (NHFD), a recent study examined 735,436 hip fractures in people between 2011 2023; 71% were women, the mean age was 82.9 years.

  • Absolute annual numbers increased from 55,832 in 2012 to 63,341 in 2022, a rise of 13.5%, but overall incidence declined from 422.8 to 412.8 per 100,000 population.
  • Trends differed by sex: female incidence decreased, while male incidence increased; the proportion occurring in men increasing, from 26.3% in 2012 to 30.3% in 2022.
  • Patients showed an increasing burden of systemic disease: the proportion ASA grades 4–5 approximately doubled.
  • An increasing proportion were admitted from their own home or sheltered housing, and fewer were housebound before their fracture. The authors note that this increases demand on discharge planning, intermediate care and home-based support services.
  • More than 20% of patients were either at risk of malnutrition or malnourished, rising to almost one-third among women.
  • Hip fracture incidence showed clear seasonal variation before the COVID-19 pandemic, with winter peaks approximately 10–20% higher than summer troughs. Presentations fell during 2020 and 2021 then returned towards pre-pandemic levels, with seasonal variation becoming re-established by 2023. The authors caution that trends during and immediately after the pandemic should be interpreted carefully because mortality displacement may have influenced the population at risk of hip fracture.
     

The study concludes that although overall hip fracture incidence has fallen, annual numbers continue to rise and patients are increasingly comorbid. The authors call for prevention strategies that include older men, sufficient capacity for increasingly complex perioperative care, and appropriate resources for orthogeriatric multidisciplinary care, discharge planning and community-based intermediate care.

Accompanying editorial

In the accompanying editorial, Prof Antony Johansen describes hip fracture as a useful model for examining wider changes in the care of older people. He notes that modern surgery and anaesthesia are now consistently good and emphasises the importance of multidisciplinary management of frailty. He describes hip fracture and its operative management as a standardised “stress test” of frailty and highlights comprehensive geriatric assessment and orthogeriatrician-led multidisciplinary care as central elements of current hip fracture management.

The editorial also highlights the increasing proportion of men sustaining hip fractures and notes that men are nearly twice as likely to die after a hip fracture, despite NHFD data suggesting that they are more independent, more mobile, better nourished and have better cognition than women. Prof Johansen stresses the need for more detailed assessment to understand these differences. He also discusses the increasing comorbidity of patients while more continue to live in their own homes, and considers the role of shared decision-making and appropriate palliative or non-operative approaches in selected patients. Finally, he cautions that population-level prediction tools may not reliably predict outcomes for an individual patient and should not lead automatically to more conservative treatment decisions.

Read the article here.

Read the editorial here.

Join the FFN

To help make the FFN vision a reality in your country, join the FFN – for free – today
Join FFN Today